In 2006, the Californian won the Telemundo reality show, 'QuinceaƱera: Mama Quiero Ser Artista' ('Sweet 15: Mom, I Want to Be an Artist'). The prize was $50,000 and a recording contract, which make us wonder if Allison has an unfair advantage.
Of course, contestants who formerly appeared on reality shows or had recording contracts are nothing new. Season 7's Carly Smithson had once released a record for a major label, while fellow finalist Syesha Mercado competed on ABC's failed 'The One: Making a Music Star.' Even runner-up David Archuleta came to the show with a 'Star Search 2' win on his resume.
Should singers with previous record contracts be allowed on 'American Idol'?